Asleep at the Wheel
An Examination of Gender and Safeguarding in Schools
March 30, 2023
A new report by Policy Exchange today reveals that schools are increasingly becoming influenced by gender ideology, to the extent that fundamental safeguarding principles are being compromised by school’s approaches to children with gender distress and their peers.
New research within this report demonstrates that many schools are failing to routinely inform parents when a child discloses gender distress, compromising single-sex spaces, and many are teaching gender identity beliefs within Relationships, Sex & Health Education (RSHE) as if they are facts. Gender affirmative care is prevalent within the school system, despite this being at odds with safeguarding principles that have been enshrined in law for decades.
The report also highlights how gender identity beliefs came to be so embedded within the school system, by tracking the influence of external agencies promoting radical and unscientific beliefs within both the Department for Education and schools themselves. This has created a safeguarding blind spot when it comes to the issue of gender, which must be rectified urgently.
This Policy Exchange report marks an important contribution to the growing
body of evidence demonstrating that urgent attention needs to be paid to the
ways children are being impacted by gender identity beliefs. Safeguarding
principles are foundational to the functioning of a responsible society, and there
is absolutely no reason why schools should ever compromise these principles.
Children deserve to explore the ways they feel about themselves and the world
in ways which do not harm them. Every issue concerning children should be
viewed through a safeguarding lens, and there is no reason why gender distress
should be any different.

Safeguarding principles are fundamental to a responsible society – and all
teachers know that. Yet this report by Policy Exchange demonstrates the
incompatibility between current practice for gender distressed children and
well-established and universally accepted safeguarding principles. The report’s
recommendations must be implemented - we cannot compromise child wellbeing
in favour of gender identity beliefs. Given what has happened within clinical
settings with Dr Cass’ damning report and the subsequent closure of GIDS,
Government must issue clearer guidance to schools so that no school facilitates
affirmative practice. Children deserve to be kept safe and action is now urgent.

“Safeguarding should always be a prime concern for schools and it is deeply
concerning that this Policy Exchange report suggests that this is being
undermined in some cases. I support high quality Relationships, Sex and Health
Education & building confidence to deliver this well should be a priority for the
Government. What should never be happening is contested theories being taught
as fact something that goes against the spirit and the letter of the Department’s
own political impartiality guidance and my committee have been pressing the
Government to update its guidance on RSHE to make sure this isn’t the case.
Parents always have the right to know about the materials being used to teach
their children and to have a say in decisions being taken about their welfare.
“Parents need the reassurance that they will be properly informed and supported
to safeguard the best interests of their children and should never have to worry
about contested ideology being imposed or medical decisions being taken without
their knowledge. I welcome the fact that the report acknowledges that the vast
majority of teachers, schools and parents want to do the right thing for children
and keep them safe. Government policy and guidance needs to support this.”

This is an outstanding report from Policy Exchange and offers an invaluable
and timely insight into the shocking extent of safeguarding failures in many
British schools. The protection of children from political indoctrination is
foundational to democratic society, and yet this report shows that we are
currently failing to protect a whole generation of children from the destructive
effects of extreme gender ideology.
For years, parents who have raised safeguarding concerns to both schools
and the Department for Education have been ignored, disbelieved or labelled as
‘bigots’. This report is a vindication of their concerns and a resounding call to
action for Government and school leaders. Biological sex is immutable and the
sex-based protections that are the hallmark of all civilised societies must apply
to children in our schools.

This report by Policy Exchange disproves the thesis that extreme political
ideology is happening in ‘just a few schools’. Rather, the research published
within this paper demonstrates that gender ideology is built into the core values
ofa number of schools. The fact that only 28% of schools are reliably informing
parents as soon as a child discloses feelings of gender distress suggests schools are actively presuming parents to be a risk to the welfare of their children.
The erosion of single-sex boundaries – at least 28% of schools are not
maintaining single-sex toilets – should concern us all. This report lays bare the
stark reality that some schools are routinely placing contested gender identity
beliefs ahead of child wellbeing. We cannot erase the notion of biological sex.
As a lawmaker, and a father of two daughters, I call on the Government to
act.

Parents place overwhelming trust in their child’s school to ensure they are
kept safe from harm. Policy Exchange reveals a systemic safeguarding blind
spot when it comes to gender-distressed children and their peers. There is no
reason why gender distress should be exempt from safeguarding standards that
have been enshrined in law for decades. The report also shows how radical and
unscientific beliefs have become embedded into the heart of the school system,
often, but not only, via Relationship and Sex Education lessons.
This is in contravention of the Education Act which forbids the partisan
teaching of ideology in schools. But it is also starting to undermine parental
faith in our school system – note, for example, the small but steady increase in
home schooling. However, at the same time, there is no doubt that schools are
being asked to take on more and more of society’s transmission of its moral and
cultural values, just as these are being increasingly contested. I therefore endorse
all of Policy Exchange’s recommendations, but two in particular.
First, it is time to stand back and commission an independent review that
involves parents, teachers, faith and community groups that is tasked to look
with fresh eyes at the school role in transmitting our society’s core values.
Second, because we will never perfect this school role, nor how it can be guided
by governments, we must embed an inalienable right for parents to view and
engage with all school curriculum materials. This is the best mechanism to
both safeguard our children and to help schools navigate their discussion around
the complex social issues arising in our modern world.

How is it that (under the radar) schools started teaching children that biological sex was somehow unimportant, or even a cultural attribute? Childhood is just when we all start emerging as sexual adults – often a confusing and troublesome time when support, guidance, and safeguarding may be needed from family and school. Importantly, children – especially girls – need privacy, protection and opportunities, in the changing room as well as on the sports field. The findings of this report suggest that many are being let down. So this is a call to arms – for schools, the relevant authorities and parents – to place children’s interests at the centre of our education provision.

Related Publications
Authors

Lottie Moore
Head of Equality and Identity (2022-2024)



